|
The
following are excerpts from an article that originally appeared in the Feb.
21, 2000 issue of Fortune magazine.
So You're a Player. Do You Need a Coach?
The hottest thing in management is the executive coach--part
boss, part consultant, part therapist. Who are these people? And
what are they doing in your company?
by Betsy
Morris
-
"People have to take more responsibility for their own
growth and development. They can't depend on human resources.
Coaches can help people come to grips with huge changes in the way we do work,
in getting through big transitions." --Mary Bradford, Sales Manager, Met
Life
-
Corporate coaching is one of the stranger wrinkles in
management these days--one of the hottest things in human resources, except
that it doesn't usually come out of human resources. (In fact, HR is
often the last to know.) It is a grassroots movement that is spreading in
some of the unlikeliest corners of corporate America, including IBM, AT&T,
and Kodak.
-
Coaches are everywhere these days. Companies hire
them to shore up executives or, in some cases, to ship them out. Division
heads hire them as change agents. Workers at all levels of the corporate
ladder, fed up with a lack of advice from inside the company, are taking
matters into their own hands and enlisting coaches for guidance on how to
improve their performance, boost their profits, and make better decisions about
everything from personnel to strategy. It's not that executive coaching
is particularly new. Chief executives and those approaching the top have
long sought counsel from personal consultants, wise board members, or
industrial psychologists. But in the past five years coaching has gone
mass-market. In the age of Every Man for Himself, every man can have a
coach--and, in an ever more commonly held view, needs one.
-
"Coaching is becoming something of a heavy
industry. It's amazing," says Warren Bennis, professor of business
administration at the University of Southern California's business school.
What exactly is a coach? Part personal consultant, part sounding
board, part manager. Yes, manager. Remember him? That person
whose job used to be to advise, motivate, and train--but whose nose is now
mostly stuck in email? For a surprising number of people, it is now the
coach--not the boss--who pushes them to hire, to fire, to fine-tune a sales
pitch, to stretch. Observers of the phenomenon say that an executive
coach often functions as a therapist, too--though the coaches themselves tend
to deny this with some fury. Warren Bennis believes that "a lot of
executive coaching is really an acceptable form of psychotherapy. It's
still tough to say, 'I'm going to see my therapist.' It's okay to say,
'I'm getting counseling from my coach.'" If ever stressed-out corporate
America could use a little couch-time, it's now. Trust in big companies
is at an all-time low. Baby-boomers have been burned; Gen Xers aren't
expecting the Corporation to take care of them. Under the circumstances,
employees are much likelier to go outside and get independent advice to help
them be better managers, says Karen Cates, assistant professor of
organizational behavior at Northwestern's Kellogg Graduate School of
Management. Beyond that, she says, mentoring systems have mostly
failed. Organizations are so lean that they don't have time for it.
You're paid for what you produce, not for time you spend developing
people. Bosses are managing by e-mail. "Given the impersonal nature
of business today, we're likely to say, 'Go take that hill--and, oh, by the
way, send me an e-mail when you get there,'" says Charles F. Cleary, chief
operating officer of Log On America, a telecommunications and Internet service
provider in Providence. Times could hardly be more trying for people
all up and down the corporate ladder. Woe to the boss who's too
authoritarian; he'll just cost the corporation good talent. Woe to the
manager who leans too heavily on hierarchy; virtual teams call for flexible
leaders who can pull together strangers in distant parts of the country and,
for the duration of a project, get them to bury their personal agendas and work
together. Meanwhile, the major currency of the manager--experience--has
never been so devalued. "You can't turn to your nice gray-haired mentor
and say, 'From your 30 years of experience, how does one handle a dot-com?'"
says Barry Mabry, a partner at Ernst & Young who is using coach.
"Nobody on earth has experienced this kind of business environment."
What's really driving the boom in coaching, says John Kotter, professor of
leadership at the Harvard Business School, is this: "As we move from 30 miles
an hour to 70 to 120 to 180...as we go from driving straight down the road to
making right turns and left turns to abandoning cars and getting on
motorcycles...the whole game changes, and a lot of people are trying to keep
up, learn how not fall off."
-
But right now coaches are so hot that credentials are
almost beside the point. What seems to matter most is word of mouth--did
the coaching work miracles for somebody you know? Corporate coaches are
in such demand that they can charge from $600 to $2,000 a month for three or
four 30- to 60-minute phone conversations. Some charge as much as $400 an
hour. So a lot of them are earning far more than psychologists or
psychiatrists.
-
Another way to look at the spread of coaching is that
is bridges the growing chasm between what managers are being asked to do and
what they have been trained to do. It is almost like the difference
between generals in peacetime and generals in war, says Harvard's Kotter.
"We have a lot of people who were trained to be superb managers but now have
horrendous leadership challenges thrown at them. I think a lot of the
coaching is aimed at trying to help people develop skills and actions that are
different from what they grew up with."
-
At many companies, coaching has become the Band-Aid for
a lot of the dysfunction caused by the trial and error of doing business in new
ways. Matrixed organizations, 360-degree performance reviews, virtual
teams--they don't always work as well in practice as in theory.
-
"Executives now are so challenged," she says.
"When you bring a group together around a task, people become commodities for
the sake of the task. They get lost."
-
Ernst partner Barry Mabry has found a coach to be a
valuable sounding board in today's crazy business climate. He'd received
a notice last year telling him that coaching would be available to Ernst &
Young partners. He made a call and soon found himself on the phone with
"a strange woman." [sic] "I was in New Orleans; she was in San
Francisco. She didn't know much about my area of work," he recalls.
But within 20 minutes, he decided she could be both trusted and helpful.
Ever since, he has had routine telephone conversations with her in which he has
discussed matters ranging from the mundane (how to improve communications with
subordinates) to the cosmic (what do you want to get out of life?). "Why
do I need a coach?" he muses. "I've wrestled with this." He's a
corporate finance partner in New Orleans. He has been with Ernst 27
years. He's successful; he's happy. His recent performance review
was quite flattering. "Perhaps it's for the same reason that Tiger Woods
needs a coach or Pete Sampras needs a coach," says Mabry. "Tiger Woods
would say, 'I know how to play golf.' But his coach is probably the most
important person in his life." The coaching phenomenon, like all mass
movements, will have its excesses; dubiously credentialed people hanging out
their shingles, no doubt; conflicting advice and agendas, quite possibly, in
offices where Everyman has a coach. But corporate America had better heed
the phenomenon, even if it falls outside the traditional corporate
organizational chart. It's a reminder that people won't run on autopilot
or by remote e-mail. No matter how much the world has changed, people on
the job still need some mentoring, some monitoring, some meaningful
interaction. And if workers can't get that in-house, why they're likely
to outsource it.
|